Featured Posts
Business
  • Porsche's Mueller takes reins at Volkswagen: Here's how lar

    Days after admitting that the world's top-selling carmaker had rigged diesel emissions to pass US tests during his tenure, longtime CEO of Volkswagen, Martin Winterkorn stepped down on Wednesday. Winterkorn, VW's boss since 2007, had come under intense pressure since the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) di[...]

  • From 'digital dinner' to FB townhall: Why PM Modi's Silicon

    Prime minister Narendra Modi has managed to get an impressive line-up of CEO meetings during his visit to the Silicon Valley later this month. With over 40,000 people already registered to attend Modi's speech, the event has now become a keenly awaited one in India.For the uninitiated, the prime minister is visitin[...]

  • Small banks mark the biggest banking revolution in India si

    Microfinance Institutions (MFIs) dominated the second set of differentiated and small finance banks announced by Reserve Bank of India (RBI) on Wednesday. Eight of the ten companies that received the in-principle nod from the central bank are MFIs.Of the other two that received approvals, one is a Rajasthan-based non[...]

  • Gold bonds are a clear winner but high chances of deposit s

    The gold bond scheme finalised by the government on Wednesday is a clear winner since the idea of issuing gold bonds can absorb a major part of the gold investment demand in the country.Presently, an estimated 300 tonnes of physical bars and coins are purchased every year for investment-purpose in India. Most of this[...]

  • Politics
  • Modi’s tears only drama? Why is it so tough to believe a st

    There was nothing unusual in the way Prime Minister Narendra Modi broke down at the Facebook Town Hall in San Jose. After all, this is not the first time that the country’s strongest political leader bared his emotional side to an audience that came to appraise him. What was unusual this time was the fact that h[...]

  • When it comes to Modi vs Sharif, we have our backs to the w

    Islamabad: Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi is an astute politician with the ability to outsmart rivals and he is aiming for the "political and military dominance of India", said a Pakistani daily that noted he was “received like a star” in the US. An editorial in The Nation on Monday said that everyone loves[...]

  • AAP MLA Somnath Bharti faces arrest after Delhi High Court

    NEW DELHI: The Delhi High Court has rejected the bail application of AAP MLA Somnath Bharti in the domestic violence case filed against him by his wife Lipika. The former Delhi law minister had moved High Court after a city court had cancelled his bail plea earlier and issued an arrest warrant against him.&[...]

  • Why the Congress petition to suspend PM Modi's Mann Ki Baat

    The Congress wants Prime Minister Narendra Modi to stop airing his Mann Ki Baat address, until the Bihar Assembly election concludes on 8 November. In fact, the party wishes to flag this as a serious issue of violation of the model code of conduct, and is petitioning the Election Commission to issue necessary direc[...]

  • Technology
  • India and Pakistan seem to be at war; this time in cyberspa

    #Cyber-war      India and Pakistan have long been k[...]

  • Government exempts WhatsApp, social media from purview of e

    NEW DELHI: Shortly after a controversy erupted over government's proposal to investigate on every message that an individual will send via WhatsApp, SMS, or Google Hangouts, the Department of Electronics and Information Technology clarified in a draft that social media websites and applications will be exempted[...]

  • Indian IT companies among world's worst paymasters

    NEW DELHI: Indian IT companies are among the 10 worst paymasters in the world, says a survey -- a mid-level IT manager draws an average salary of $41,213 while his Swiss counterpart gets over four times more.According to recruitment platform MyHiringClub.com's Worldwide IT Salary 2015 survey, India was ranked 7[...]

  • Bengaluru first Indian city to get Uber car-pool service

    BENGALURU: Taxi-hailing app Uber will be rolling out UberPool in Bengaluru in the coming weeks, making it the first city in India chosen for its car-pooling pilot. With UberPool, riders can share a ride and split the cost with another person who happens to be requesting a ride along a similar route. Uber will n[...]

  • Entertainment
  • Ranbir Kapoor's special working birthday on the sets of 'Ae

    The baby-faced, towel-dropping Saawariya debutant turns 33 today. And in the 8 years since Ranbir Kapoor's debut film, he has been a part of many films. However, the birthday boy recently started shooting for Karan Johar's Ae Dil Hai Mushkil in London, and had a working birthday this year. However, tha[...]

  • FIR registered against Farhan Akhtar, Ranbir Kapoor

    Ranbir Kapoor An FIR has been registered against Bollywood actor-director Farhan Akhtar and actor Ranbir Kapoor for criminal breach of trust and forgery for promoting an online shopping site which is allegedly "duping" customers. The FIR has been registered by a lawyer Rajat Bansal, a resident of Keshav Nag[...]

  • Konkona Sensharma: My mother is shy around my son

    A day before this meeting with Konkona Sensharma happened, her husband Ranvir Shorey and she took to Twitter to announce their separation. Both of them also conveyed their decision to co-parent their young son Haroon. Konkona is clear she will not answer any questions pertaining to the above because she has never s[...]

  • We Are Your Friends review: In Zac Efron's hands, even EDM

    There aren’t many movies on electronic dance music (EDM) or its industrial-techno-underground flavours. The 2004 Michael Dowse film It’s All Gone Pete Tong was one of the first of its kind and it turned out to be a truly stunning sendoff to EDM fans, thanks to it’s unique plot featuring a deaf DJ, mouthwatering Ibi[...]

  • Sports
  • Manpreet Kaur breaks national shot put record on road to Ri

    Railways shot putter Manpreet Kaur today became the latest Indian athlete to qualify for next year's Olympics when she shattered an 18-year-old national record en route to a sixth title at the 55th National Open Athletics Championship today.The Patiala-based shot putter threw 17.96 metres in her second attempt to c[...]

  • Champions League: Chelsea cruise but Dinamo Zagreb stun 10-

    The Champions League season is only one match day old, but it will be tough for anyone to better Alessandro Florenzi's eye-popping strike that gave Roma a 1-1 draw with defending champion Barcelona on Wednesday.Florenzi launched an audacious 60-yard (meter) lob from near the sideline and watched it sail over Barcelon[...]

  • Sanjay Bangar is right: We have been too quick to judge Roh

    Rohit Sharma, the much criticised India batsman, recently received some support from India batting coach Sanjay Bangar, who urged the critics to compare Rohit’s record to those of others at the same stage of their careers."If you look at the numbers, he has played 13 Test matches and scored 800-900 (870 runs) runs a[...]

  • With an eye on 2019 World Cup, it's time for Virat Kohli to

    It was only a matter of time before the murmuring began.With an historic series win in Sri Lanka under his belt, Virat Kohli, India’s Test captain, is reportedly being considered for the one-day captaincy as well. Considering that MS Dhoni’s aura shines brightest in the 50-over game, where he is still a formidable [...]

  • Cars
  • 2015 Frankfurt Motor Show: 2016 Suzuki Baleno to be showcas

    The 66th Frankfurt Motor Show will witness the world debut of the all-new Baleno. Suzuki plans to showcase their new "ideal hatchback" to the media on September 15, 2015. The motor show will be open to public from September 17-27, 2015. In its new form, the Baleno takes after the IK-2 concept that was shown at th[...]

  • Maruti Suzuki launches S-Cross

    Country’s largest car maker Maruti Suzuki on Wednesday launched its crossover hatchback S-Cross priced in the range of Rs.8.34 lakh and Rs.13.74 lakh as it looks to cement its position in the premium car market. The S-Cross will compete with models such as Hyundai’s recently-launched Creta, Renault’s Duster, Ford’s [...]

  • CCI slaps Hyundai with fine of Rs 420.26 cr for restricting

    New Delhi: Coming down hard on carmakers found to be restricting sale of spare parts in open market, fair trade regulator CCI on Tuesday imposed a penalty of Rs 420.26 crore on Hyundai Motor India and asked two others -- Reva and Premier -- to 'cease and desist' from anti-competitive practices. This follows penaltie[...]

  • Recent Articles

    Zuckerberg Vows to Daughter He’ll Donate 99% of His Facebook Shares

    SAN FRANCISCO — Mark Zuckerberg, the co-founder and chief executive of Facebook, announced on Tuesday that he and his wife would give 99 percent of their Facebook shares “during our lives” — holdings currently worth more than $45 billion — to charitable purposes.From Our AdvertisersThe pledge was made in an open lett[...]

    02 Dec 2015 | 0 commentsView Post

    Mark Zuckerberg and Priscilla Chan announce baby girl – and massive charity initiative

    In a Facebook post to newborn child Max, the Facebook CEO says he will administer the initiative himself using 99% of shares in company’s stock.   The Zuckerbergs announced two births on Tuesday: a baby girl, and to one of the world’s biggest charities. That sterling spoon you might have been considering f[...]

    02 Dec 2015 | 0 commentsView Post

    Osama cited Bapu as inspiration in 1993 speech

    cassettes were discovered. The cache soon passed many hands from an Afghan family to a cassette shop and then to a CNN cameraman, finally making its way to the Afghan Media Project at Williams College in Massachusetts, who asked Flagg Miller — an expert in Arabic literature and culture from the University of Californ[...]

    02 Oct 2015 | 0 commentsView Post

    Water on Mars? Here’s why Nasa believes there can be signs of life on the red planet

    Recently, planetary scientists detected hydrated salts on these slopes at Horowitz crater, corroborating their original hypothesis that the streaks are indeed formed by liquid water. Image Credit: nasa.tumblr.com The dark narrow streaks called recurring slope lineae are up to few hundred meters in length.[...]

    29 Sep 2015 | 0 commentsView Post

    Ranbir Kapoor's special working birthday on the sets of 'Ae Dil Hai Mushkil'

    The baby-faced, towel-dropping Saawariya debutant turns 33 today. And in the 8 years since Ranbir Kapoor's debut film, he has been a part of many films. However, the birthday boy recently started shooting for Karan Johar's Ae Dil Hai Mushkil in London, and had a working birthday this year. However, tha[...]

    29 Sep 2015 | 0 commentsView Post

    Patels should learn from Jats and Gurjars: Government can't allot quota to whoever it pleases

    A woman cop charges a woman during a clash in Jamnagar on Wednesday a day after Patidar community rally for reservation. PTI
    The irony of an affluent community of an equally affluent and vibrant state, hailed for its growth model, seeking benefits of reservation for survival and sustenance may have confounded analysts. But, the agitation by Patels of Gujarat isn't without precedence or history; it is almost replica of similar protests by Jats and Gurjars of Rajasthan.

    The idea of a mob demanding policy changes by coming out on to the streets, resorting to violence, blackmailing politicians and getting the government genuflect to it, was implemented with varying degrees of success in Rajasthan.

    It would be worthwhile to revisit the inclusion of Jats among OBCs and the ramifications of the decision to understand why the Patels have taken recourse to political heft and violence. This will show how the recent agitation is an unavoidable outcome of the process set into motion by VP Singh, Inder Kumar Gujaral, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, Rajasthan chief minister Vasundhara Raje and her predecessor Ashok Gehlot.

    Jats, like Patels, are an influential community in Rajasthan. Though they are believed to be around 15 percent of the state's population, their importance is exaggerated by their heavy concentration in a few districts of western Rajasthan and their ability to vote as a single political entity.

    When the Mandal Commission report was implemented by the VP Singh government, Jats were not part of the Other Backward Classes (OBCs). Soon, they starting demanding their inclusion in the category and reservation benefits. Their demand was a perfect opportunity for the government to reconsider the reservation policy and the claim of various castes and communities to quota benefits. But, instead of looking at the policy afresh, the government decided to consider the claims of the community and referred their case to the National Commission for Backward Castes (NCBC).

    The NCBC examined the claims of Jats of Rajasthan, Haryana, Delhi, Western Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh for OBC status. But it found only the demand of the Jats of Rajasthan, excluding those of Bharatpur and Dholpur, valid.

    More politics followed. Bhairon Singh Shekhawat, the then chief minister of Rajasthan, was not in favour of tinkering with the OBC list. So, he ignored the recommendations of the NCBC. At the Centre, the Gujaral government refused to act on them, citing its care-taker status.

    In 1999, while addressing an election rally in Rajasthan's Sikar district, Vajpayee promised inclusion of Jats among OBCs. Just a year ago, the Congress had won 18 out of the 25 Lok Sabha seats in Rajasthan. But in 1999, in the elections that followed Vajpayee's promise, the Congress tally was reduced to nine. Convinced that its quota politics had turned the tide, the Vajpayee government that took over included Jats among OBCs in the Central list. The then chief minister of Rajasthan, Gehlot, also succumbed to the demand of Jats for quota benefits in the state.

    The success of the Jat stir is an important milestone on the continuum of quota politics. One, it established the template for future agitations by demonstrating that the political might can be used successfully to arm-twist governments. And two, it established that the quota pie can be redistributed even in the absence of new data and statistics. (The OBC list are based on the 1931 census but the Jats based their claim on post-Independence socio-economic changes).

    We can see an echo of the Jat stir when Hardik Patel, leader of the Gujarat agitation, threatens to uproot the Lotus from his state in the next election if his community is not included in the OBC list, or economic status doesn't replace caste as the basis for reservation. Patels are anywhere between 15 to 20 percent of the Gujarat population. Like the Jats who kept Congress in power in Rajasthan, they are believed to be the BJP's loyal vote bank. Aware of their importance, Hardik thinks he can make the government bend in front of the Patel mob.

    But, tinkering with the OBC pie could be disastrous. It can set off a chain of events that has the potential to stoke unrest in every caste and community, leading to more violence and agitations. Moreover, it can create legal problems that would challenge the Indian Constitution.

    When Jats were included in the OBC category in Rajasthan, it set off another round of agitations, leading to violence and social upheaval.

    In 2007, Gurjars, part of OBCs, intensified their demand for being categorised as Scheduled Tribe. Their claim was triggered by the fear that Jats, who are economically, socially and financially more resourceful than other backward classes, were usurping all the quota benefits.

    But, the Gurjars, who are nearly 5 percent of Rajasthan's population, were denied ST status, primarily because of the presence of the powerful Meena community, the major beneficiaries of reservation extended to tribes. Frustrated by the logjam, the Gurjars turned violent in 2007, and then once again a year later, leading to police firing and violent clashes that claimed more than 100 lives.

    This is what is boiled down to ultimately: Gurjars did not want Jats as competitors; but the Jats were against bifurcation of the OBC list. The Gurjars wanted to be recognised as Scheduled Tribes; but the dominant tribe of Rajasthan, the Meenas, was opposed to it. And the Rajasthan government did not have the courage to upset any of these powerful communities.

    So, it resorted to the charade of creating a separate category for Gurjars and giving them five percent reservation. But this ran into legal trouble since in announcing reservation to this new category of backwards, the government exceeded the 49 percent limit on quota set in the Constitution.

    Apart from inviting legal trouble, the government also annoyed the general category, which protested additional reservation in the state. Since then, there have been demands for either scrapping of the existing system, or extension of benefits to Brahmins and Rajputs on economic basis. The simmering caste volcano is waiting to erupt.

    What are the lessons for the government from the experience in Rajasthan? One, it can't resort to ad-hocism while apportioning quota benefits. The policy of addressing the claims of one community can lead to dangerous consequences. The government needs to look at the entire system of reservation and the criteria for inclusion afresh.

    Two, politics has to be kept out of the social justice system. Traditional definitions of backward and forward are in a flux because of socio-economic changes since Independence. There are creamy layers and deprived sections in almost every community. The traditional method of classifying people will only contribute to rising disparity, and, thus, resentment and anger.

    Hardik Patel has given us an opportunity to re-examine the reservation system afresh. We should be wary of his dangerous demand for inclusion of Patels among OBCs, but grateful for suggesting that everybody be given an equal opportunity to succeed in India.

    Share and Enjoy:

    0 comments for this post

    Leave a reply

    We will keep You Updated...
    Sign up to receive breaking news
    as well as receive other site updates!
    Subscribe via RSS Feed subscribe to feeds
    Sponsors
    Get more updatesNEWS#
    TemplateNewsSpicytricks.com
    Popular Posts
    Recent Stories
  • Zuckerberg Vows to Daughter He’ll Donate 99% of His Faceboo

    SAN FRANCISCO — Mark Zuckerberg, the co-founder and chief executive of Facebook, announced on Tuesday that he and his wife would give 99 percent of their Facebook shares “during our lives” — holdings currently worth more than $45 billion — to charitable purposes.From Our AdvertisersThe pledge was made in an open lett[...]

  • Mark Zuckerberg and Priscilla Chan announce baby girl – an

    In a Facebook post to newborn child Max, the Facebook CEO says he will administer the initiative himself using 99% of shares in company’s stock.   The Zuckerbergs announced two births on Tuesday: a baby girl, and to one of the world’s biggest charities. That sterling spoon you might have been considering f[...]

  • Osama cited Bapu as inspiration in 1993 speech

    cassettes were discovered. The cache soon passed many hands from an Afghan family to a cassette shop and then to a CNN cameraman, finally making its way to the Afghan Media Project at Williams College in Massachusetts, who asked Flagg Miller — an expert in Arabic literature and culture from the University of Californ[...]

  • Water on Mars? Here’s why Nasa believes there can be signs

    Recently, planetary scientists detected hydrated salts on these slopes at Horowitz crater, corroborating their original hypothesis that the streaks are indeed formed by liquid water. Image Credit: nasa.tumblr.com The dark narrow streaks called recurring slope lineae are up to few hundred meters in length.[...]

  • Ranbir Kapoor's special working birthday on the sets of 'Ae

    The baby-faced, towel-dropping Saawariya debutant turns 33 today. And in the 8 years since Ranbir Kapoor's debut film, he has been a part of many films. However, the birthday boy recently started shooting for Karan Johar's Ae Dil Hai Mushkil in London, and had a working birthday this year. However, tha[...]

  • Modi’s tears only drama? Why is it so tough to believe a st

    There was nothing unusual in the way Prime Minister Narendra Modi broke down at the Facebook Town Hall in San Jose. After all, this is not the first time that the country’s strongest political leader bared his emotional side to an audience that came to appraise him. What was unusual this time was the fact that h[...]

  • Connect with Facebook
    Sponsors
    Search
    Archives
    Categories
    Blog Archives
    Tag Cloud